EMPLOYEE OWNERSHIP FACT SHEET
THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR EMPLOYEE OWNERSHIP
Growth of Employee Ownership: As of the end of 1993, the National
Center for Employee Ownership estimated there was approximately 9,500
employee stock owner plans (ESOPs) and similar ownership plans cover
over 10,000,000 employees. In addition, several million employees
participate in plans that offer stock options to most or all of a
company's employees or in which most or all employees buy stock,
usually at a discount (precise numbers are not available). Employee
ownership has been growing at roughly 300 - 600 new plans and 300,000
- 600,000 new plan participants a year in recent years. ESOPs now
control over $150 billion in corporate stock. Employees own another
$140 billion in company stock through 401(k) plans and an unknown
amount through broad stock option and stock purchase plans. At least
100 large public companies, and thousands of smaller companies, now
give stock options to most or all employees.
Major Uses of Employee Ownership: About half the plans are used to
provide a market for the shares of a departing owner of a profitable,
closely-held company. Most of the remainder are used either as a
supplemental employee benefit plan or a means to borrow money in a
tax-favored manner. Less than 5% of the plans are used either as a
defense against a hostile takeover or to save a failing company.
Employee Ownership and Corporate Performance: Companies that combine
employee ownership with employee workplace participation programs show
subgains in performance. A 1986 National Center for Employee Ownership
study found that employee ownership firms that practice participative
management grow 8-11% per year faster with their ownership plans than
they would have without them. Note, however, that participation plans
alone have little impact on company performance. These NCEO data have
been confirmed by several subsequent academic studies that find both
the same direction and magnitude of results. ESOPs also perform well
in large leveraged transactions. A 1989 NCEO study of the largest
majority leveraged ESOP transactions found that these companies were
doing as well as or better than their competitors, despite their heavy
debt. A 1991 NCEO study showed that 30% of non-ESOP leveraged buyouts
were bankrupt, in de, or in serious trouble, while only 10% of ESOP
LBOs faced similar problems.
How ESOPs Work: Companies set up a trust fund for employees and
contribute either cash to buy company stock, contribute shares
directly to the plan, or have the plan borrow money to buy shares. If
the plan borrows money, the company makes contributions to the plan to
enable it to repay the loan. Contributions to the plan are
tax-deductible. Employees pay no tax on the contribution until they
receive the stock when they leave or retire. They then either sell it
on the market or back to the company. Provided ESOPs own 30% of
company stock, owners of private firms selling to an ESOP can defer
taxation on their gains by reinvesting in securities of other company,
and, in certain cases, banks can deduct 50% of the interest income
they receive from loans to ESOPs.
How Employees Fare: According to a 1990 National Center for Employee
Ownership study, an employee making $20,000 a year in a typical ESOP
would accumulate $31,000 in stock over 10 years. Only 3% of all ESOP
participants give up pension plans for their ESOPs and only 4% of the
ESOP companies require wage concessions. For the large majority of
ESOP participants, ownership is an additional benefit contributed to
them by the company.
Major Examples of Employee Owned Firms: The large companies
principally owned by employees are: Publix Supermarkets (80,000
employees), United Airlines (75,000 employees), Science Applications
(16,000 employees), Avis (car rental, 12,500 employees), Ralph M.
Parsons Corp. (engineering, 10,000 employees), and Amsted Industries
(8,000 employees). Among other notable employee ownership firms are
W.L. Gore Associates (maker of Gore-Tex), Quad/Graphics (one of the
country's largest printers), Journal Communications (publisher of the
Milwaukee Journal and Milwaukee Sentinel), and Hallmark Cards.
Public Company ESOPs:Eighty-five percent of all ESOPs are in private
companies, but ESOPs have become more popular in public firms as well.
Public company ESOPs typically own 5-20% of the firms stock. About 15%
are used as a takeover defense, and the rest to replace existing
matching contributions to other employee benefit plans (something
relatively rare in private firms). Employees own over 4% of over 1,000
public firms.
About the National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO):The NCEO is a
private, non-profit membership, information, and research
organization. Supported by its members and services, the NCEO serves
as a central source of information on employee ownership. Attribution
Requested.
_________________________________________________________________
The National Center for Employee Ownership
1201 Martin Luther King Jr. Way
Oakland, CA 94612
510-272-9461
email: nceo@iia.org
_________________________________________________________________
[Toolbar]