|
|
<< Employer Health Coverage Plummets | Main | Block Grants as Anti-Urban Policy >> September 18, 2003Volokh Gets It WrongUS Founded on Progressive TaxationEugene Volokh is accusing Wesley Clark of being historically ignorant. The complaint? Clark attacked Bush's tax cuts as a betrayal of America's progressive history: The people that need the money and deserve the money are the people who are paying less, not the people who are paying more. I thought this country was founded on a principle of progressive taxation.Volokh snidely dismisses Clark by saying, "Somehow I slept through the class session in American History where they explained just how the country was founded'on a principle of progressive taxation.'" But it's Volokh who has his history wrong. For those of us for whom this country was founded in the "New Birth of Freedom" that ended slavery and completed the Constitution with the post-Civil War Amendments, the United States WAS founded on progressive taxation. In fact, the first progressive income tax was in 1862 to fund the Union troops. From the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA): It was a "progressive" tax in that it initially levied a tax of 3 percent on annual incomes over $600 but less than $10,000 and a tax of 5 percent on any income over $10,000. In 1864 the rates increased and the ceiling dropped so that incomes between $600 and $5,000 were taxed at 5 percent, with a 10 percent rate on the excess over $5,000. Passed as an emergency measure to finance the Union cause in the Civil War, the first income tax generated approximately $55 million in government revenues during the war. Paying the taxes was viewed as part of the patriotic war effort, and the whole country was proud when the merchant prince A. T. Stewart paid $400,000 in taxes on an income of $4 million.So yes, pride in a progressive income tax is EXACTLY what this country was founded upon. It's worth noting that the Congress assumed it had the power to pass an income tax on that basis and revived it in the 1890s, only to have a rightwing Supreme Court strike the income tax down. This led to passage of the 16th Amendment, further ratifying progressive taxation as a founding principle of our constitutional system. One thing that conservatives don't understand about America-- liberty was not founded in 1776. It's been a continual process with each generation having to refound this country in struggle -- a little bit of revolution periodically in Thomas Jefferson's phrase. But there is little question that our modern constitutional system was only established with the Civil War, and progressive taxation was at the heart of that effort. Posted by Nathan at September 18, 2003 05:37 PM Related posts: ... and Why That's a Good Thing - Jan 01, 2005 Bad Day for Human Rights - Nov 30, 2004
Trackback PingsTrackBack URL for this entry: CommentsSpelled his name with an extra C in the title. Posted by: eric at September 19, 2003 02:24 AM Thanks Eric. Posted by: Nathan at September 19, 2003 09:05 AM Tell Wesley to NOT correct his previous statement by saying that the country was founded in 1862. Posted by: Chad Peterson at September 22, 2003 10:58 AM Post a comment
|
Series-
Social Security
Past Series
Current Weblog
January 04, 2005 January 03, 2005 January 02, 2005 January 01, 2005 ... and Why That's a Good Thing - Judge Richard Posner is guest blogging at Leiter Reports and has a post on why morality has to influence politics... MORE... December 31, 2004 December 30, 2004 December 29, 2004 December 28, 2004 December 24, 2004 December 22, 2004 December 21, 2004 December 20, 2004 December 18, 2004 December 17, 2004 December 16, 2004
Referrers to site
|